Toronto is a city where diverse culinary traditions thrive, and Italian cuisine holds a special place in the hearts of food lovers. From cozy trattorias to upscale dining establishments, the city offers a remarkable variety of options to savor authentic Italian dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for classic pasta, wood-fired pizza, or indulgent gelato, the 7 best Italian restaurants in Toronto promise an unforgettable gastronomic experience. With fresh, high-quality ingredients and recipes rooted in tradition, these spots showcase the rich and vibrant flavors of Italy in the heart of Canada.
7
Number of companies
8464
Verified reviews
4,44
Average rating
1. Fresca Pizza and Pasta
★
★
★
★
★
4,6/5
302 College St, M5T 1R9, Toronto
- Italian restaurant
- Pizza restaurant
Why we chose them
Fresca Pizza and Pasta is a charming Italian restaurant specializing in pizza and pasta, offering a cozy and inviting atmosphere for its customers. Known for being a tiny corner stop for slices and pies, it delivers an authentic Italian dining experience that appeals to both locals and visitors. With its focus on quality and simplicity, the restaurant ensures every dish is crafted with care, making it a delightful option for those craving traditional Italian flavors.
As a dedicated pizza restaurant, Fresca Pizza and Pasta stands out for its commitment to serving delicious, freshly-made pizzas that cater to a variety of tastes. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice or indulging in a full pie, this spot is perfect for a casual yet satisfying meal. Its emphasis on providing an accessible and enjoyable dining experience makes it a notable addition to our directory for anyone seeking authentic Italian cuisine in a relaxed setting.
2. Donatello Restaurant
★
★
★
★
★
4,3/5
37 Elm St, M5G 1H1, Toronto
- Italian restaurant
- Fine dining restaurant
- Vegetarian restaurant
Why we chose them
Donatello Restaurant has earned its place as a standout dining destination in downtown Toronto, offering an exceptional experience for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine. Known for its quaint charm and classic dishes, this award-winning establishment has been recognized as a “Choice award winner” for the past three years. Whether you’re indulging in their expertly prepared steak, seafood, or pasta, the restaurant caters to diverse tastes, including vegetarian options, making it a versatile choice for fine dining. Its warm atmosphere is complemented by private rooms, wheelchair accessibility, and an inviting outdoor patio, ensuring comfort for all guests.
Perfectly balancing elegance and accessibility, this fine dining restaurant is ideal for a range of occasions, from intimate dinners to group gatherings. Guests can enjoy a full-service bar and the convenience of take-out options, making it a flexible choice for those on the go. With its prime location in the heart of downtown Toronto and a dedication to delivering high-quality Italian cuisine, this restaurant captures the essence of traditional flavors while providing a modern and inclusive dining experience.
3. Cafe Oro di Napoli
★
★
★
★
★
4,6/5
75 Jarvis St, M5C 2H1, Toronto
- Italian restaurant
- Restaurant
Why we chose them
Cafe Oro di Napoli brings the essence of authentic Italian cuisine to Toronto’s Old Town with a modern twist. Known for its signature Neapolitan pizzas cooked in a Stefano Ferrara pizza oven and homemade pastas crafted from the finest ingredients, this Italian restaurant offers a culinary experience that is both delicious and inviting. The cozy dining room, adorned with greenery, provides a serene environment for patrons to watch their meals come to life while enjoying a selection of expertly curated wines and cocktails from various Italian regions.
Established in 2019, this vibrant venue has quickly become a neighborhood favorite, celebrated for its artisanal menu featuring crowd-pleasers like the Pappardelle Osso Buco and Pizza Oro. Whether dining in for a relaxed meal or hosting a private function, guests can expect exceptional food, drinks, and company. The restaurant also offers physical gift cards, making it easy to share the joy of authentic Italian fare with loved ones. With its dedication to quality and passion for Italian cuisine, it’s no surprise this modern eatery is a standout in Toronto’s dining scene.
4. Queen Margherita Pizza
★
★
★
★
★
4,3/5
785 Annette St, M6S 2E4, Toronto
- Pizza restaurant
- Italian restaurant
- Takeout restaurant
- Pizza takeaway
- Restaurant
Why we chose them
Queen Margherita Pizza is a standout destination for lovers of authentic Neapolitan cuisine, offering a menu crafted with passion and ethically sourced ingredients. Known for its signature Neapolitan-style pizzas, the restaurant channels the rich culinary heritage of Italy while embracing local flavors from Toronto’s backyard. The industrial decor adds a modern twist to the dining experience, making it a unique spot for enjoying traditional dishes. From dine-in to takeout, the restaurant seamlessly blends quality and convenience, catering to food enthusiasts with a taste for genuine Italian flavors.
Inspired by the story of Queen Margherita of Italy and her namesake pizza, the restaurant is dedicated to preserving the art of traditional pizza-making while introducing a contemporary flair. With services that include a full-service restaurant, takeout, and catering, it has become a beloved choice for those seeking exceptional Italian dishes in Toronto. The passion for great food, the city, and its community is evident in every aspect of the restaurant, making it a noteworthy addition to our directory.
5. Bellissimo Pizzeria & Ristorante
★
★
★
★
★
4,3/5
164 The Esplanade, M5A 4H2, Toronto
- Italian restaurant
- Pasta shop
- Pizza restaurant
Why we chose them
Bellissimo Pizzeria & Ristorante offers an authentic dining experience that captures the essence of Italian cuisine. Known for its unpretentious charm and inviting patio, this establishment is dedicated to serving high-quality meals that exceed expectations every time. Specializing in a variety of Italian dishes, including freshly made pasta and mouthwatering pizzas, Bellissimo ensures that every visit or delivery brings “a taste of Italy” to its customers. Whether dining in or enjoying their convenient delivery service through platforms like Uber Eats, Skip The Dishes, DoorDash, and Ritual, the restaurant is committed to providing delicious meals for any occasion.
With a strong focus on customer satisfaction, Bellissimo prides itself on its consistently excellent food and welcoming atmosphere. This Italian eatery stands out for its adaptability, catering to both dine-in guests and those looking for a cozy night at home with expertly prepared meals. The restaurant has also earned praise for its catering services, making it a go-to choice for events and gatherings. Bellissimo’s dedication to combining tradition with convenience makes it a distinguished addition to our directory of exceptional dining establishments.
6. Mattachioni
★
★
★
★
★
4,6/5
1617 Dupont St, M6P 3S8, Toronto
- Italian restaurant
Why we chose them
Mattachioni stands out as a must-visit for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine, offering a delightful blend of simplicity and quality. Known for its signature thin-crust pizza and sandwiches crafted on house-baked sourdough bread, this unassuming bodega elevates comfort food to an art form. Their menu also includes fresh salads and irresistible treats, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.
With its focus on delivering high-quality, handcrafted dishes, this Italian restaurant has earned a reputation for excellence. The commitment to using fresh, artisanal ingredients shines through in every bite, from the perfectly baked crusts to the thoughtfully prepared toppings and fillings. Whether you’re craving a satisfying sandwich or a classic slice of pizza, the atmosphere and flavors make it a standout choice for any food enthusiast.
7. Marcello's Pizzeria
★
★
★
★
★
4,4/5
1163 St Clair Ave W, M6H 3L9, Toronto
- Italian restaurant
- Pizza restaurant
Why we chose them
Marcello’s Pizzeria is a beloved destination for Italian cuisine, offering a warm and casual atmosphere perfect for indulging in authentic pasta dishes and expertly crafted wood-fired pizzas. Known for its dedication to quality and flavor, this restaurant specializes in providing a true taste of Italy through its carefully curated menu. Patrons can enjoy a variety of signature offerings, all prepared with fresh ingredients and traditional techniques, making it a go-to spot for Italian food enthusiasts.
With a focus on delivering exceptional dining experiences, Marcello’s Pizzeria operates as both an Italian restaurant and a pizza restaurant, catering to diverse tastes. Its inviting ambiance and commitment to culinary excellence make it a standout choice for those seeking delicious meals in a relaxed setting. Whether dining in or ordering online, customers can savor the rich flavors of Italy, making this establishment a cherished addition to any food lover’s list.
Frequently asked questions
What types of Italian dishes are typically offered at restaurants in Toronto?
Italian restaurants in Toronto offer a variety of dishes, including classic pasta like lasagna, spaghetti carbonara, and ravioli, wood-fired pizzas with fresh toppings, freshly baked breads like ciabatta and focaccia, and desserts such as tiramisu and gelato. Many also feature seasonal menus with regional Italian specialties.
What is the average price range for dining at an Italian restaurant in Toronto?
The price range for Italian dining in Toronto varies depending on the restaurant. Casual dining establishments typically charge between €10-€20 per dish, while fine dining restaurants can range from €35-€60 or more per dish.
Do Italian restaurants in Toronto offer takeout or delivery options?
Yes, many Italian restaurants in Toronto offer takeout and delivery options, making it convenient to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine at home. Be sure to check with the restaurant for availability and any additional charges for delivery services.
How do I choose a good Italian restaurant in Toronto?
To choose a good Italian restaurant, consider factors like customer reviews, menu offerings, ambiance, and whether the restaurant uses fresh, high-quality ingredients. Authenticity and a focus on traditional recipes are also key indicators of a great Italian dining experience.
Are there family-friendly Italian restaurants in Toronto?
Yes, many Italian restaurants in Toronto offer family-friendly environments, with menus that cater to both adults and children. These establishments often feature a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, making them great for group outings or family dinners.
What should I consider when booking a fine dining Italian restaurant in Toronto?
When booking a fine dining Italian restaurant, consider the menu options, wine list, ambiance, and dress code. It's also a good idea to make reservations in advance, especially for weekend or holiday dining, as these venues can be popular and fill up quickly.
Do Italian restaurants in Toronto accommodate dietary restrictions or preferences?
Many Italian restaurants in Toronto are happy to accommodate dietary restrictions and preferences, such as gluten-free, vegetarian, or vegan options. It’s recommended to contact the restaurant in advance to confirm availability and discuss any specific needs.
Do Italian restaurants in Toronto offer wine pairings with their meals?
Yes, many Italian restaurants in Toronto feature extensive wine lists, including Italian and international selections, and offer wine pairings to complement their dishes. Some restaurants may even have in-house sommeliers to recommend the best pairings for your meal.
